• Freelance Attorney Platform
  • (949) 400-0798
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Montage Legal Group

  • About
  • Attorneys
  • Services
  • Blog
  • Press
  • Join Platform
  • Hire Freelance Attorneys

From BigLaw to Freelance Law™ Blog

Freelance attorneys modernizing legal practice.

Home Blog ethics

Does Engaging an Out-of-State Freelance Lawyer Not Barred in California Violate Any Ethical Rules?

September 5, 2017

Should California law firms be concerned about violating ethical rules prohibiting aiding and abetting in the unlawful practice of law when they use an out-of-state freelance lawyer not barred in California on a legal project? The short answer is no, as long as the hiring law firm is a member of the state bar, and retains control over the representation and exercises independent judgment in reviewing the out-of-state lawyer’s work.

“No person shall practice law in California unless the person is an active member of the State Bar.”  Cal. Bus. Prof. Code § 6125.  Further, under California Rule of Professional Responsibility 1-120, no member of the State Bar may “assist in, solicit, or induce any violation” of the rules of professional conduct or the state bar.   California Rule of Professional Conduct 1-300(A) states, “A member shall not aid any person or entity in the unauthorized practice of law.”

These ethical rules apply when a California law firm contracts with attorneys not admitted in California or uses a Legal Process Outsourcing (“LPO”) company that employs off-shore individuals or out-of-state attorneys.  See Birbower, Montalbano, Condon & Frank, PC v. Superior Court, (1998) 17 Cal.4th 119 (refining the scope of the unauthorized practice of law to include legal work by New York attorneys in connection with prospective private arbitration in California).  While the State Bar Act does not define the practice of law, Courts have discussed its meaning.  In Birbower, the Court held, “The primary inquiry is whether the unlicensed lawyer engaged in sufficient activities in the state or created a continuing relationship with the California client that included legal duties and obligations.” Birbower, (1998) 17 Cal.4th 119, 129.

California ethical rules permit law firms to contract for certain legal services by attorneys not licensed in California, including drafting legal pleadings, as long as the law firm remains ultimately responsible for the final work product. Jacob v. State Bar, 19 Cal. 3d 359, 363 (1977); People v. Perez, 24 Cal. 3d 133, 143 (1979).

Winterrowd v. Am. Gen’l Annuity Ins., 556 F.3d 815 (9th Cir. 2009) is instructive on this issue.  In Winterrowd, a lawyer barred in Oregon but not in California assisted a California lawyer litigating a case before the United States District Court for the Central District of California.  The Oregon attorney did not “appear” before the court, did not sign any pleadings, and had little contact with opposing counsel or clients, and the California attorney supervised the Oregon attorney. The court held that there was no ethical violation under these circumstances. See Orange County Bar Association Formal Opinion 2014-1 (concluding that “the mere act of Out-of-State Lawyer’s ghostwriting a document for California Counsel of Record is not likely to constitute the unauthorized practice of law in California.”); San Diego County Bar Association Ethics Opinion 2007-1 (“the attorney does not aid in the unauthorized practice of law where he retains supervisory control over and responsibility for those tasks constituting the practice of law.”); Orange County Bar Formal Opinion No. 94-002 (1994) (opining that a paralegal who does work of a preparatory nature, such as drafting initial estate planning documents, is not engaged in the unauthorized practice of law where the attorney supervising the paralegal maintains a “direct relationship” with the client, citing ABA Ethical Consideration 3-6.).

Thus, simply engaging an out-of-state contract lawyer to ghost-write generally does not violate ethical rules, so long as an attorney licensed by the state retains full control over the representation and exercises independent judgment in reviewing the non-licensed attorney’s work.

For more information on the ethics of contract lawyering, see Stay Ethical While Growing Your Firm, published in the ABA’s “Law Practice Today” July 2017 issue.

FacebookTweetLinkedInEmail

Filed Under: ethics, freelance attorney, legal outsourcing

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to receive blog updates via email.

For information about which freelance attorneys have experience in a particular area of law, or for information about rates, please contact Montage Legal Group at 949-400-0798 or [email protected].

Footer

Montage Legal Group

P.O. Box 14455
Irvine, CA 92623

Phone: (949) 400-0798

General Inquiries: [email protected]

To join our platform, email your resume to: [email protected]

More information about joining the Montage platform.
Unfortunately, we cannot do informational phone calls.

Latest News

  • Montage Sponsoring and Speaking at the California Women Lawyers Annual Meeting
  • A Simple Approach to a Complicated Problem: AI for Transactional Legal Agreements
  • Twenty Years After Brobeck’s Collapse: How to Survive & Thrive in Times of Recession and Career Crisis
  • Celebrating Women’s History Month: Meet Women Who Inspire Us
  • Erin Giglia Featured on Counsel-to-Counsel Podcast

© 2023 · Montage Legal Group · Terms · Privacy · Accessibility

 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Share this ArticleLike this article? Email it to a friend!

    Email sent!